Winners and losers on election night

Jane Dittmar was unable to overcome the odds in the GOP-heavy 5th District. Photo Eze Amos Jane Dittmar was unable to overcome the odds in the GOP-heavy 5th District. Photo Eze Amos

As the presidential election played out across the United States, the battle for both the White House and an open seat in the U.S. House of Representatives played out in Charlottesville on its own small scale.

At Carver Recreation Center near the Downtown Mall, afternoon voters were greeted by a pair of smiling volunteers from the Charlottesville Democratic Party who offered sample ballots. A uniformed sheriff’s deputy stood facing the street, watching for trouble that never materialized. Typical of city precincts, no Republican representatives were present.

Polling places throughout the city and in parts of Albemarle County were heavily manned by Dem volunteers. But as the results came in, the relative strength of the Democratic organization in Charlottesville was overwhelmed by the overall numbers throughout the 5th Congressional District.

“We’ve known for quite a while that our field effort, our ground game was very energetic and very extensive,” said Tom Vandever, a former mayor of Charlottesville and campaign manager for Democratic congressional nominee Jane Dittmar. As he waited for the polls to close among a throng of supporters at the Democrats’ celebration in the lobby of the brand new Residence Inn on West Main Street, the tone of the room was optimistic.

“We haven’t seen the same evidence from [Republican Tom Garrett’s] campaign,” said Vandever, who noted that the Republican Campaign Committee dropped over a million dollars on his campaign. “That’s a lot of money to drop on a campaign and it’s certainly helped him,” said Vandever. “But we’ve known all along that getting our voters to the polls on Election Day was going to be critical. We’ve had hundreds of volunteers making phone calls and knocking on doors all over the district.”

At 7:30pm, shortly after the polls closed, expectations in the Democratic camp were high for Clinton and at least hopeful for Dittmar. Smiling volunteers laid out tins of homemade cookies.

“We’re hoping to see at least 65 percent for Jane in Albemarle County, at least 75 percent in Charlottesville,” Vandever said.

A victorious Tom Garrett is flanked by state Senator Frank Wagner, who is running for governor, and state Senator Bryce Reeves, who wants to be lieutenant governor in 2017. Photo Eze Amos

A few blocks away, Charlottesville’s Republicans had gathered in a tightly packed crowd at Random Row Brewing Company to watch the results come in. Free beer flowed from the taps amid occasional chants of “Trump, Trump, Trump!”

“I woke up this morning knowing that I needed to go poll watch in whatever poll wasn’t covered in my city,” said Barbara Null, chair of the Republican Party of Charlottesville.

“Tom Garrett, I love,” she said. “He’s a great guy.” Null said the former Louisa commonwealth’s attorney will do what he says and he’s honest. “I worked very hard for his campaign and I’m really excited,” said Null. “He’s got all these great ideas, like letting people delay taking Social Security to pay off their student debt.”

Null would have liked more GOPers to work the polls in the city, but that’s always a problem, she said. “You don’t register by party so there aren’t a lot of Republican leaning people in the city but there’s a good core and we use them.” She added, “I think we did good.”

Vandever knew that his candidate had a tough fight outside of Charlottesville.

“The 5th District is a difficult district,” Vandever said. “We don’t know the impact that the Trump campaign is going to be. Jane is tied to Clinton, Tom is tied to Trump. Clinton has to stay relatively close to Trump in the 5th for Jane to catapult over. If Clinton goes down by five, six points in the 5th, it’s going to be a tough haul for Jane to win. But if it’s within three, then we’ve got the springboard to pull it off.”

Dittmar was crushed 58 percent to 42 percent. Charlottesville’s well-organized Dems brought her 79 percent within the city, while in Albemarle, she took 57 percent.

Frank Squillace embraces his wife, Jane Dittmar, after she concedes Tuesday night. Photo Eze Amos
Frank Squillace embraces his wife, Jane Dittmar, after she concedes Tuesday night. Photo Eze Amos

In the 5th District overall, Donald Trump received 53 points to Hillary Clinton’s 42.

As the night wore on, the Democratic gathering was reduced to a few dozen people who had given up on Dittmar but grimly hoped for the defeat of Trump. Empty wine glasses littered the stone tables where supporters sat watching MSNBC and CNN. A hotel employee announced that the remaining cookies were about to be thrown in the trash. Last call.

Back at Random Row, the Republican crowd had dwindled somewhat by midnight but grown no quieter as they watched the large television screens hung over the bar. Fox News called Pennsylvania for Trump. “USA, USA, USA!” chanted a group of men by the bar. Lagers and ales were served up in tulip-shaped stemware. They had run clear out of pint glasses hours ago.

Posted In:     News

Tags:     , ,

Previous Post

Will George Huguely’s trial be further delayed?

Next Post

City regulations could have an effect on new breweries

Our comments system is designed to foster a lively debate of ideas, offer a forum for the exchange of ad hoc information, and solicit honest, respectful feedback about the work we do. We’re glad you’re participating. Here are a few simple rules to follow, which should be relatively straightforward.

1) Don’t call people names or accuse them of things you cannot support.
2) Don’t direct foul language, racial slurs, or offensive terms at other commenters or our staff.
3) Don’t use the discussion on our site for commercial (or shameless personal) promotion.

We reserve the right to remove posts and ban commenters who violate any of the rules listed above, or the spirit of the discussion. We’re trying to create a safe space for a wide range of people to express themselves, and we believe that goal can only be achieved through thoughtful, sensitive editorial control.

If you have questions or comments about our policies or about a specific post, please send an e-mail to

Leave a Reply

Notify of