Past in the present: A Batesville pizza kitchen stays the same—and that’s O.K.


Cabinetry was created from wood found on the property. The kitchen sits in the corner of the two-story house, which was the original Craigs Store, built in 1822. What the space lacks in bells and whistles, it makes up for in views of pastures and nearby farms. Photo: Christian Hommel Cabinetry was created from wood found on the property. The kitchen sits in the corner of the two-story house, which was the original Craigs Store, built in 1822. What the space lacks in bells and whistles, it makes up for in views of pastures and nearby farms. Photo: Christian Hommel

It’s true what people say: All the great things are simple, and they are especially so if they’re old and cherished. To enter Nancy and Michael McCarthy’s Batesville home is like stepping back in time. Through its iron bar front door to the original wood paneling that follows the space throughout the open floorplan, it’s hard to believe that this is the original Craigs Store, built in 1822—a structure that was once a stage coach stop, a post office, and a general store and that has surely witnessed many lives and daily occurrences in a time that now seems a very distant past.

The McCarthys bought the property in 2008, around the same time they purchased Dr. Ho’s Humble Pie, the beloved pizza joint in North Garden. The house fell in their lap; they were not actively looking to relocate. In fact, they’d just completed a chef’s kitchen in their Downtown Charlottesville residence.

Photo: Christian Hommel
Photo: Christian Hommel

“I just had a very dramatic reaction to it,” said Nancy. “It felt like a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity and I remember walking in the master bedroom and getting teary eyed.”

The kitchen sits on the right corner of the large first floor of the two-story house; it is small and dark, but charming and absolutely perfect. The family who lived in the house in the late 1970s and ’80s did most of the renovations and used materials found around the property.

“The house really lends itself to family life,” said Nancy, looking over at her two young sons, 3 and 1. “It’s very functional. If you are standing in the kitchen making a meal, you can see what the kids are doing and that makes it really easy.”

The McCarthys haven’t done much to renovate the 1970s-era kitchen, aside from changing a light fixture, replacing the old hood fan with a new one, and adding stylish crown molding. But they like it that way; it reflects their new way of life, away from the hustle and bustle of the city. They do have plans to add a soapstone countertop, but are not ready to alter the feel of the house.

“The simpler we live, the happier I am,” she said.

Simple is only in terms of space and finishes, because what the house lacks in that department, it makes up in spectacular views of pastures and nearby farms and an overall peace that is lost in most modern dwellings.

Photo: Christian Hommel
Photo: Christian Hommel

“It’s really majestic and beautiful. We got to sit on the front porch a lot when we first bought it, because we didn’t have children,” Nancy said. “We used to sit there at night and listen to nothing and everything; you could hear the cows chewing the grass.”

Standing at the stainless steel sink, one can work a pizza dough and look out to the hilly meadows in the sun and feel completely at ease. During the “Snowmageddon” a couple of years ago, the silence and white landscape was worthy of a postcard.

“We felt like we were at the end of the earth, because there was nobody driving by,” she said.

Little objects dispersed around the house remind them of the tradition they bought into: the framed 1899 ABC license that hangs in the first floor bathroom; the kitchen cabinets made out of wood from the property; the current playroom that was once a post office. Everywhere you stand, history surrounds you with welcoming warmth—especially the kitchen.

Photo: Christian Hommel
Photo: Christian Hommel

“Food is the heart and soul of our family,” said Nancy. “It feeds us, literally.” It is not surprising considering Michael is a trained chef who bakes between 40 and 150 pizzas every day. Over a lunch of pizza with Virginia ham, figs, blue cheese, golden raisins soaked in cherry vinegar and balsamic, the McCarthys’ reminisce on the old days of city living and the new freedom of living in the country, entertaining relatives, and using the kitchen every day as a family.

“It’s neat to live in a house so old, where so many people have lived in before,” Nancy said.

Posted In:     Living


Previous Post

The art of letting go: Getting kids to the leave the nest

Next Post

Value, uncompromised: Don’t sacrifice quality when it comes to buying inexpensive wines

Our comments system is designed to foster a lively debate of ideas, offer a forum for the exchange of ad hoc information, and solicit honest, respectful feedback about the work we do. We’re glad you’re participating. Here are a few simple rules to follow, which should be relatively straightforward.

1) Don’t call people names or accuse them of things you cannot support.
2) Don’t direct foul language, racial slurs, or offensive terms at other commenters or our staff.
3) Don’t use the discussion on our site for commercial (or shameless personal) promotion.

We reserve the right to remove posts and ban commenters who violate any of the rules listed above, or the spirit of the discussion. We’re trying to create a safe space for a wide range of people to express themselves, and we believe that goal can only be achieved through thoughtful, sensitive editorial control.

If you have questions or comments about our policies or about a specific post, please send an e-mail to

Leave a Reply

Notify of