HOME | CONTACT | WRITE TO THE EDITOR | WORK AT C-VILLE
www.nycshuttle.com/schedule.php

About FEEDBACK

This blog expands on Andrew's regular column in C-VILLE Weekly, sharing insights and notable happenings within the arts world of Charlottesville, VA. Readers should feel encouraged to share their insights, and to help broaden the dialogue that surrounds the arts in our community.

Follow FEEDBACK

RSS


Twitter




www.c-ville.com/index.php?cat=1991712083826863&ShowArticl
www.jeffersontheater.com
Feedback
by Andrew Cedermark
by Brendan Fitzgerald, December 20th, 2009 08:56pm

I may not know Jeremy Taylor too well, but he strikes me as the sort of person whose wrath is as difficult to incur as that of a Labrador puppy. The local artist takes it easy on the earth with his work, and we recently praised him for his efforts in eco-friendly and non-toxic art.

That being said, Taylor posted an interesting comparison on the blog that he shares with his wife, Allyson Mellberg Taylor: photos of his work featuring repeated and interconnected triangles, and a bowl featuring a similar pattern at Urban Outfitters. His response? No aggression, no animosity—simply a proclamation that, henceforth, he plans to retire that design from his work. (He also includes this link to a blog called Urban Counterfeiters.)

Taylor's situation presents a nice opportunity to consider what I'll call "similarities" in their many forms. More than a year ago, a former local designer and friend had a similar issue crop up with a t-shirt. (Read the account here; long since settled.) Also, since having the comparison pointed out to me, I've always been slightly troubled by how closely the Jam's "Start!" resembles the Beatles' "Taxman." And let's not forget Waldo Jaquith's post in the VQR about Chris Anderson's Free (also covered by UVA professor Siva Vaidhyanathan).

Ever been troubled by similarities between two seemingly separate designs, songs, books, etc? How do you calibrate your moral scale for this sort of situation? Does Girl Talk make you angry, or make you dance? Leave some thoughts below.

Comments
Thanks for reading our Blog Brendan! Here is a new one that I just figured out the other day:

Belle and Sebastian's "White Collar Boy" was ripped off by some band called Muse, in a song called "Uprising" Lame! Listen to the first 20 seconds of each song.

Good call on the Jam too.

Sometimes being vaguely copied can be flattering, and telling of someone's particular influences, but other times it can be downright upsetting and feel like a huge violation.(especially if someone straight up steals your ideas or imagery or music or words, etc.) The internet makes things even more complicated as we artists are all sharing and posting our work online... this forum for showing work has not been clearly mapped out yet and its easy to cross boundaries. (there is also this cool aspect of meeting people from all over and feeling like we really do have some sort of hive mind! But it begs the question of how you protect yourself and your hard work) (this might explain why we don't have an individual website for our art outside of our blog...) Anyhow its an interesting topic. I look forward to hearing other peoples responses.

Best,

Allyson
Mrs. Taylor December 22nd, 2009 05:26pm
Have your say
*
*
*
Your comment will be displayed after it has been reviewed by the blog author. Please refer to our comments policy if you have any questions, or email editor@c-ville.com.
http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/7F3K73S
click on the day to see the events for that day
 Prev   Jul 2010  Next  
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31
 
event: pick your type
 
music: pick your venue
 
dining: pick your cuisine
 
www.charlottesvilledermatology.com/
charlottesvillepavilion.com/
c-ville.com/index.php?cat=1990602080504511
doubletree1.hilton.com
www.charlottesvilledermatology.com/
www.undertheroof.com/
www.omnihotels.com/FindAHotel/Charlottesville/Dining.aspx
www.charlottesvillepavilion.com/fridaysafterfive/
Circulation VerifiedCopyright © 2010, Portico Publications
Copyright Info | Portico Corporate
Powered by PLANet w3 CMS Content Management System
PLANet Systems Group 2010